Technical and economic comparison between PV-RO system and RO-Solar Rankine system. Case study: Thirasia island
Abstract
This paper presents the technical characteristics as well as an economic comparison of two autonomous desalination systems.
The first system concerns the laboratory experimental results of a direct coupled PV-SWRO desalination system without batteries equipped with a hydraulic energy recovery device of the Clark pump type. The PV system consists of 18 Arco-Solar monocristaline PV panels, with total peak power of 846 W. These panels are directly connected to a brushless DC motor of 510 W, powering a rotary vane pump as low pressure pump. The clark pump utilizes the high pressure brine to intensify the feed pressure to the RO desalination system. The desalination system has a capacity of 0.1 m3/h. The specific energy recovery of this system has been experimentally found to be in the range of 3.8–6 kWh/m3 depending on the feed water temperature and the feed water salinity.
The second system is an organic solar Rankine system for RO desalination. The heat produced by the solar collectors’ field is transformed to mechanical power through an organic Rankine cycle process. The shaft power produced drives the high pressure pump of the RO unit, initiating the desalination process. The prototype system consists of vacuum tube solar collectors 90 m2, a Rankine engine of 100 kW and an RO unit of 0.3 m3/h. The energy recovery system of the RO unit consists of a pair of axial piston pumps (APP) manufactured by Danfoss. One of them operates reversely, as turbine, exploiting the hydraulic energy of the brine stream.
The aim of the economic analysis is not only to estimate the cost of each system but also to compare them on the same basis, in order to allow a meaningful comparison. Hence, each system cost is determined having utilised the same economic assumptions like interest, operating expenses, etc. Moreover, these desalination systems can provide sufficient amounts of potable water for the local needs of a small island, like Thirasia, (Cyclades, Greece) at a cost as low as 7.77 ɛ/m3, very close to that of water hauling.
References (7)
- D. Manolakos et al.
Design of an autonomous low-temperature solar Rankine cycle system for reverse osmosis desalination
Desalination
(2005) - D. Manolakos et al.
Experimental evaluation of an autonomous low temperature solar Rankine cycle system for reverse osmosis desalination
Desalination
(2007) - I.C. Karagiannis et al.
Current status of water desalination in the Aegean Islands
Desalination
(2007)
Cited by (98)
Hybrid desalination system driven by solar energy: Optimization and case study
2024, Applied Thermal EngineeringRecently, to solve the water scarcity crisis, challenges have arisen in exploring solar desalination systems with low power consumption. Along with that, a small-scale hybrid humidification-dehumidification /reverse osmosis desalination unit powered by concentrated photovoltaic/thermal solar technology is theoretically optimized and investigated. The study introduced the novelty of desalination system optimization and thermal energy cascade utilization with mass recovery to reduce energy consumption and overall system liquid discharge. Performance parameters such as; solar system productivity, freshwater productivity, freshwater salinity, recovery ratio, and energy consumption were evaluated under the climatic data of Sanya, China. The study also examined the sensitivity of climatic factors on the system's productivity and performance. Results showed, that as reverse osmosis operating pressure increased from 40 to 50 bars, the pressure exchanger integrated, and the SW30-HR380 membrane type was selected, it significantly improved productivity by 90.8 %, reduced energy consumption by 58.2 %, and increased recovery ratio by 74.8 % at 700 W/m2 solar radiation. Additionally, the improved system produces an average 4 m3/d (548 L/m2 d) productivity, 500–650 ppm salinity at 40 % recovery ratio, and 4 kW/m3 energy consumption, outperforming previous studies. Finally, solar radiation significantly impacts desalination system performance, while wind speed has the least effect.
Renewable energy-driven membrane distillation in the context of life cycle assessment
2024, Renewable and Sustainable Energy ReviewsDesalination and water treatment processes have seen a worldwide increase due to increasingly limited access to drinking water sources. In this context, the article focuses on membrane distillation (MD), an affordable and promising separation process that can use low-grade waste and alternative energy sources. Therefore, the use of alternative energy sources, especially renewable energy (RE), whose global production has consistently increased, plays an important role in MD development. Any comprehensive procedure to be developed has to document the environmental impact of the process at every stage of its life-cycle following standardized ISO procedures. The review describes the main aspects that have to be analyzed in relation to the connection between the different configurations of MD and the use of RE-PV systems, wind energy, hydropower, solar thermal, geothermal systems, and the Organic Rankine Cycle. Life cycle assessment (LCA), life cycle cost (LCC), and social life cycle assessment (SLCA) are discussed as current trends. The analysis concludes that the use of RE to support MD is a promising development, particularly with geothermal energy. Additionally, MD is a potential process for resource recovery from brine, and a rethink is needed to treat brine as a raw material rather than a waste. LCA, LCC, or SLCA are considered harmonious and complementary methods which can be combined in the evaluation of MD-RE systems. The study findings offer the potential for sustainable water treatment through RE with the use of combined LCA ensuring a comprehensive and environmentally responsible approach to MD-RE systems.
Renewable energy systems for water desalination applications: A comprehensive review
2023, Energy Conversion and ManagementRenewable energy sources are expected to provide viable alternative solutions for water desalination to address the issues of high-energy consumption and negative environmental impacts. However, the compatibility of each desalination process with solar technology strongly depends on the kind of energy required as thermal (collectors) or electrical (photovoltaic panel) and its availability. Due to the Bulkiness of solar-based systems and intermittency and non-uniformity of solar energy, several issues arise when it comes to its utilization to drive the desalination processes while targeting positive competitiveness with fossil fuels powered systems. The water production costs of large-scale renewable energy-assisted desalination systems are still higher than those of traditional fossil fuels. This study comprehensively summarizes the efforts made in renewable energy utilization in the desalination industry, with an emphasis on technological advances and economics. This study also includes recent developments and improvements in desalination processes, renewable energy technologies, and energy storage systems. In addition, this review highlights the geographical distribution, potential application, and main barriers and challenges of renewable energy-based desalination. Finally, the current and expected costs of water production using conventional and renewable energy systems were presented. Thermal desalination processes consume more energy than membrane-based systems because the former consumes a large amount of energy for water vaporization. Regarding the production cost of renewable-energy-powered desalination systems, the wave-powered reverse osmosis (RO) system had the lowest production cost, followed by solar multiple effect distillation (MED), solar multi-stage flash (MSF), wind RO, and wind mechanical vapor compression (MVC), whereas the PV-powered RO system had the highest production cost.
Energy and economic performance assessment of a solar-assisted regenerative vacuum membrane desalination system
2023, Applied Thermal EngineeringVacuum membrane water desalination is a promising technology for freshwater production with the advantages of low conduction heat loss and mass transfer resistance, compared to other membrane technologies. Such systems can be driven by solar thermal collectors for green water production, yet there is a lack of dynamic system simulations in the literature to comprehensively assess the energy and economic system performance and evaluate the impact of brine recirculation as a method of regeneration, especially under hot desert climates where solar resources are abundant, but freshwater resources are scarce (e.g., the northern coast of Egypt, considered as the case study here). In this study, a dynamic system simulation model is developed in TRNSYS, where a new “Type” is introduced for the vacuum membrane module. Initial sizing of the system with ∼20 % solar fraction resulted in annual average gained output ratio and specific thermal energy consumption of 2.51 and 133.5 kWh/m3, respectively, with levelized cost of water and payback period of 14.7 USD/m3 and 1.53 years, respectively. By increasing the solar collectors’ area from 8 to 16 m2, the levelized cost of water increased by 14.54 %. The storage volume was highly influential on the solar fraction, which increased by 101.39 % as the volume increased from 0.3 to 0.7 m3. Increasing the membrane area from 0.3 to 0.5 m2 increased the gained output ratio by 76.75 % while decreasing the levelized cost of water by 14.79 %. Internal heat regeneration through brine recirculation enhanced the system performance at lower recirculation ratios. Without recirculation, the levelized cost of water increased by 117.41 % and the system met the daily distillate water demand for only 90 days of the year.
Renewable energy sources utilized for membrane desalination processes
2023, Green Membrane Technologies towards Environmental SustainabilityDesalination has mostly been used to produce drinkable water due to the rapid increase in water scarcity. On the other hand, desalination processes require more energy than that of conventional water treatment methods. To decrease the consumption of fossil fuel and the cost of freshwater production, renewable energy sources (RESs) to power the desalination processes have been introduced. The RES used in desalination has a broad spectrum from photovoltaics, concentrated solar power, and wind energy to integrated RESs. In this chapter, desalination processes that are powered by RESs are discussed. Also, new generations of RESs in membrane desalination systems are introduced.
Small-scale seawater desalination system with energy recovery devices is the mainstream technical solution to cope with fresh water issue and tight power supply in the exploitation of islands. Aiming at the complex working conditions, the adaptability of piston type high pressure pump integrated with energy recovery device (HPP-ERD) is investigated through the numerical simulation and all-year-round island desalination. The numerical results indicate that the consecutive flowrate regulation, broad pressure sustainability and uniform temperature distribution are realized in HPP-ERD within the flowrate of 5.30 m3/h, the pressure of 5.50 MPa, and the temperature of 25 °C. The experimental results prove that HPP-ERD exhibits excellent stability and adaptability at the starting stage and stopping stage, and achieves stable operation in the pressure range between 3.00 MPa and 5.50 MPa. The all-year-round operation demonstrates that HPP-ERD can adapt to the seawater temperature ranging from 0.85 °C to 25.69 °C and the humidity between 63% and 85%. The total internal leakage maintains nearly constant at 0.19 m3/h which contributes to the annual specific energy consumption (SEC) of 3.80 kWh/m3. This investigation provides researchers and engineers with the application references of HPP-ERD in island desalination system.