First-principles investigation on the role of interstitial site preference on the hydrogen-induced disproportionation of ZrCo and its doped alloys

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2020.01.183Get rights and content

Highlights

  • Hydride thermal and lattice stabilities are dominated by hydrogen storage capacity.

  • The disproportionation performance is found to be strongly dependent upon the 8e site.

  • Interstitial hole size and bonding characteristic are correlated with hydride properties.

  • Anti-disproportionation performance before and after Ti/Rh doping is examined.

Abstract

There are two phase structures involved in ZrCo hydrides (ZrCoHx). When x ≤ 1, the α-phase hydride is generated when hydrogen atoms occupy the 3c and 12i sites. When 1 < x ≤ 3, three interstitial sites of 4c2, 8f1, and 8e are occupied by H, and in turn the β-phase hydride is formed. There is a disproportionation reaction in β-phase hydrides during hydrogen discharging process to produce the ZrH2 phase with higher thermal stability, leading to inferior hydrogen storage performance. In this study, the influence of hydrogen storage capacity on thermodynamic and lattice stabilities of α- and β-phase hydrides for each occupancy position is investigated under the framework of the first-principles study. The results indicate that the binding energy in the 3c site is higher compared with the 12i site under the condition of identical hydrogen storage capacity. Similarly, the binding energy is the largest for the 8e site compared with the other two sites, indicating that there is the least energy released in the reaction process. Thus, the 8e site is proved as the most unfavorable site in β-phase ZrCo hydrides, which is due to its degraded thermodynamic stability. Also, comparisons of mechanical properties and total density of states for each site in two hydride phases are presented to demonstrate that compound lattice stability in the 8e site is the poorest, suggesting that it is more likely to produce disproportionation. Furthermore, the dependence of hydrogen storage performance of β-phase hydrides on Ti/Rh doping is examined as well. It is discovered that there is improved thermodynamic stability and lattice stability in the 8e site for Zr0.875Ti0.125Co after Zr is partially substituted by Ti, which significantly enhances the disproportionation resistance. In contrast, when Co is partially replaced by Rh, there is a deterioration in the thermodynamic stability of ZrCo0.875Rh0.125 in the 8e site, but its lattice stability is somewhat improved.

Introduction

Compared with traditional hydrogen storage methods in gaseous or liquid states, the solid-state hydrogen storage is typically characterized by the form of reversible metal hydrides, which has been verified to be more reliable for storing abundant hydrogen and its isotopes with high efficiency and compactness [1,2]. As a type of hydrogen storage material for replacing metal uranium (U), zirconium-cobalt (ZrCo) is not radioactive and pyrophoric at room temperature, and its hydrogen equilibrium pressure is fairly low (about 10−3 Pa). Especially at 673 K, such a pressure reaches up to 105 Pa with excellent hydrogen absorption and desorption kinetics [3]. Therefore, ZrCo is deemed as one of the promising materials for International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) to store and recover hydrogen isotopes (deuterium and tritium) [[4], [5], [6]]. However, in comparison with uranium, ZrCo exhibits poor thermal cycling performance under high temperature, which becomes the biggest obstacle for its practical applications [7]. During hydrogen absorption process, H atoms enter into the 3c and 12i sites, and consequently there is the occurrence of α-phase ZrCoHx (x = 0–1), the unit cell structure of which is characterized by the body-centered cubic structure (BCC) with no phase transition. By increasing the hydrogen amount till H/ZrCo >1, the lattice distortion degree is aggravated gradually, and in turn the heat generated by the exothermal reaction makes the hydride temperature rise. Under the coupling action between lattice distortion and high temperature, the mechanical stress combined with thermal stress lead to material phase transition, thereby generating β-phase ZrCoHx (x = 1–3) with orthorhombic crystal structure, where H may occupy 4c2, 8f1, and 8e sites. When there are ZrCo2 and ZrH2 phases with superior thermal stability being generated under the condition of repeated hydrogen absorption-desorption cycles [8,9], the disproportionation reaction occurs, which is given to:2ZrCoHx=ZrCo2+ZrH2+(x1)H2

In fact, this behavior is mainly induced by high temperature combined with equilibrium hydrogen pressure [10,11]. Due to the presence of ZrH2 phase with preferable thermal stability and the ZrCo2 phase without hydrogen absorption, the above-mentioned reaction is irreversible in nature under normal operating temperatures [12,13]. As a result, after multiple hydrogen charging and discharging cycles, the disproportionation reaction leads to a decrease in the amount of ZrCo alloys, which directly affect overall hydrogen storage performance. Konishi et al. [14] found that if disproportionation products were heated to above 773 K in vacuum for several hours, the single-phase ZrCo was produced by the reverse reaction. Contrarily, Besserer et al. [15] experimentally revealed that there was the disproportionation reaction occurring from room temperature to 673 K in the first 5 cycles, and its rate increased with increasing the number of cycles. After 7 thermal cycles, the disproportionation rate remained unchanged. Furthermore, the hydrogen storage capacity decreases significantly beyond 25 cycles. It is evident that about 25 times is completely insufficient for the number of hydrogen absorption and desorption cycles in the ITER project [5,16]. Therefore, it is of great importance to improve hydrogen storage performance of ZrCo alloys for promoting practical applications, especially by enhancing the anti-disproportionation ability.

In recent years, much work committed to conducting experimental studies on the partial substitution of Zr or Co by the third alloy, like as Ti, Hf, Cu, and Nb [[17], [18], [19], [20]], to restraint hydride disproportionation reaction occurrence. For example, Zhang et al. [19] used Ti, Ni, Sc, and Fe elements to partially replace Zr or Co, and prepared Zr0.8Ti0.2Co, ZrCo0.8Ni0.2, Zr0.8Sc0.2Co, and ZrCo0.8Fe0.2 by arc melting, respectively. Some parameters, such as lattice constant, phase structure, and thermal stability before and after the substitution, were measured availably. The disproportionation kinetics results showed that the Ti substitution could effectively improve hydride anti-disproportionation capability, while Fe, Sc, or Ni doping accelerated the disproportionation reaction. The disproportionation rate sequence was: ZrCo0.8Ni0.2 > Zr0.8Sc0.2Co > ZrCo0.8Fe0.2 > ZrCo. Besides, they believed that the unstable hydrogen position within the unit cell was the driving force for the disproportionation reaction, and the partial substitution of Zr or Co affected the anti-disproportionation performance by altering its stability. In addition, Peng et al. [20] focused on hydrogen storage properties of Zr(1-x)HfxCo (x = 0, 0.1, 0.2, and 0.3), demonstrating that when the temperature ranged from 673 to 823 K at approximately 200 kPa of hydrogen pressure, Zr0.7Hf0.3CoH3 possessed superior anti-disproportionation performance in comparison with ZrCoH3, because the plateau pressure in hydrogen absorption was higher and the corresponding hydride decomposition temperature was lower after the Hf doping. Recently, Weng et al. [21] conducted an investigation on the influence of Mn substitution for Co on the initial activation behavior and thermodynamics of ZrCo alloys. Wang et al. [22] employed the electroless plating method to reveal the catalyst effect of Pd coating on ZrCo hydriding kinetic property.

On the other hand, substantial attempts focused on hydrogen storage properties of ZrCo and its doped compounds from a perspective of microscopic scale using theoretical calculations. Chattaraj et al. [23] calculated structural, electronic, and thermodynamic properties of ZrCo and ZrCoH3 by the first-principles method, highlighting the role of Zr and Co on the bonding with H in resulting hydrides. Yang et al. [24,25] used the density functional theory to evaluate the anti-disproportionation ability of ZrCoH3 and its doped alloys from the cell level. The calculation results showed that the 4c2 and 8f1 sites were more energy-efficient than the 8e site, but none of the three positions occupied by H were as stable as ZrH2. Besides, the disproportionation ability of ZrCo after being replaced by various alloy elements was assessed comprehensively, by considering hydrogen diffusion process, 8e site character, and Zr–H bonding length.

Most experimental and theoretical studies indicated that disproportionation occurrence was likely due to the hydrogen specific interstitial site in the ZrCo unit cell, which had been partially confirmed by neutron diffraction experiments [[26], [27], [28]]. It was discovered from those experiments that the occurrence of disproportionation was attributed to the occupancy of H at the 8e site in ZrCoH3. The disproportionation reaction was also found to be dominated by the hydrogen storage capacity and the corresponding Zr–H bonding length. In other words, there was better anti-disproportionation ability when the hydrogen storage capacity was lower and the bonding length was longer in the 8e site.

In fact, most studies concentrated on investigating hydrogen storage properties associated with ZrCo and its doped alloys. However, very few of the models attempted to investigate the effect of hydrogen storage capacity on disproportionation performance in each interstitial site. Compared with previous studies, what the nicest feature the present study has is that it takes into account the effects of interstitial site and hydrogen storage content on ZrCo anti-disproportionation ability.

In this work, the first-principles calculation based on the density functional theory is performed to explore the influences of hydrogen storage content on formation enthalpy, lattice constant, and total density of states in each position, and in turn thermodynamic and lattice stabilities are evaluated comprehensively. In particular, the crystal performance when H occupies in the 8e site is analyzed in details to promote an understanding of hydrogen storage behavior. Furthermore, the Zr0.875Ti0.125Co and ZrCo0.875Rh0.125 compounds are formed by partial substitution of Zr and Co by Ti and Rh, and then resultant disproportionation performance is studied.

Section snippets

Modeling

In general, the first-principles calculations based on quantum mechanics are taken as an effective tool for accurately obtaining electronic structures by directly solving the Schrödinger equation without relying on any empirical and semi-empirical parameters [29]. In this work, crystal properties of ZrCo and its doping hydrides were investigated by the density functional theory (DFT), which was achieved through Cambridge Serial Total Energy Package (CASTEP) program in Material Studios software.

Results and discussion

For the analytical purpose, the 3c, 12i, 4c2, 8f1, and 8e sites that are occupied by the hydrogen are considered, which are represented by H(3c), H(12i), H(4c2), H(8f1), and H(8e), respectively. Also, ZrCoH(x, y) is used to represent the ZrCo hydride formed by H atoms occupying the y interstitial site, and the amount of hydrogen is x atom/f.u..

Conclusions

This study has conducted first-principles calculations to investigate the stability of ZrCo hydrides when H occupies each interstitial site, and then the anti-disproportionation performance of resultant hydrides when H is located at the 8e site is evaluated comprehensively. Besides, the bonding properties and TDOS of hydrides after the Ti/Rh doping are examined as well.

The computational results show that when H occupies the 3c or 8e site, the hydride crystal formation enthalpy is larger than

Acknowledgements

The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support of the Venture & Innovation Support Program for Chongqing Overseas Returnees under grant number cx2018078, the Natural Science Foundation Project of CQ CSTC under grant number cstc2018jcyjAX0581, the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities under grant number XDJK2018B002, and the Special Foundation for Distinguished Talents from Institute of Materials of CAEP.

References (50)

  • G.H. Zhang et al.

    Effects and mechanism of Ti, Ni, Sc, Fe substitution on the thermal stability of zirconium cobalt-hydrogen system

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2015)
  • L.X. Peng et al.

    Hydrogen-induced disproportionation characteristics of Zr(1-x)Hf(x)Co (x = 0, 0.1, 0.2 and 0.3) alloys

    Fusion Eng Des

    (2013)
  • C.C. Weng et al.

    Effect of Mn substitution for Co on the structural, kinetic, and thermodynamic characteristics of ZrCo1-xMnx (x = 0-0.1) alloys for tritium storage

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2017)
  • F. Wang et al.

    Effect of catalytic Pd coating on the hydrogen storage performances of ZrCo alloy by electroless plating method

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2017)
  • D. Chattaraj et al.

    Structure, electronic and thermodynamic properties of ZrCo and ZrCoH3: a first-principles study

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2012)
  • G. Yang et al.

    Effects of alloying substitutions on the anti-disproportionation behavior of ZrCo alloy

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2017)
  • G. Yang et al.

    Theoretical study of ZrCoH3 and the anti-disproportionation ability of alloying elements

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2018)
  • R.A. Jat et al.

    Determination of deuterium site occupancy in ZrCoD3 and its role in improved durability of Zr-Co-Ni deuterides against disproportionation

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2014)
  • R.A. Jat et al.

    Structural and hydrogen isotope storage properties of Zr-Co-Fe alloy

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2015)
  • R.A. Jat et al.

    An analogy of interstitial site occupancy and hydrogen induced disproportionation of Zr1-xTixCo ternary alloys

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2017)
  • Q.L. Tang et al.

    A density functional study on properties of a Cu3Zn material and CO adsorption onto its surfaces

    Appl Surf Sci

    (2016)
  • K.F. Garrity et al.

    Pseudopotentials for high-throughput DFT calculations

    Comput Mater Sci

    (2014)
  • Y. Bouhadda et al.

    Hydrogen solid storage: first-principles study of ZrNiH3

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2009)
  • D. Chattaraj et al.

    Structural, electronic, elastic, vibrational and thermodynamic properties of ZrNi and ZrNiH3: a comprehensive study through first principles approach

    Int J Hydrogen Energy

    (2016)
  • D.G. Westlake

    Stoichiometries and interstitial site occupation in the hydrides of ZrNi and other isostructural intermetallic compounds

    J Less Common Met

    (1980)
  • Cited by (0)

    View full text