Elsevier

Chemical Physics Letters

Volume 715, January 2019, Pages 77-83
Chemical Physics Letters

Research paper
Using a collagen heterotrimer to screen for cation-π interactions to stabilize triple helices

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cplett.2018.10.073Get rights and content

Highlights

  • A mutant library of cation-π interactions to collagen stability was constructed based on a collagen heterotrimer.

  • Five axial and one lateral cation-π pairs showed stabilizing effects on collagen.

  • Axial RF pair not only had high stabilizing effects but also occurred frequently in natural collagen sequences.

Abstract

As one of non-covalent forces to stabilize protein, cation-π interactions in collagen have been received much attention. Three chains of collagen form its characteristic secondary structure, triple helices. Based on a collagen heterotrimer, abc, a library containing 15 mutant peptides was built to characterize the stabilizing effects of 24 pairwise cation-π interactions. The six stabilizing pairs, axial FK, YK, WK, RF, and RW, and lateral RF, have been identified, among which only axial RF frequently occurs in natural collagen sequences. This suggests that cation-π interactions might not be optimized in natural collagen.

Introduction

Collagen is the most abundant protein in higher animal. Collagen is composed of three chains forming triple helix. Sequence of each chain is successive triplets Gly-X-Y, where X is often Pro and Y is often (4R)-hydroxyproline (Hyp or O). Except for Pro and Hyp, there are high percentages of Lys and Arg in natural collagen [1], [2]. Lys could form strong salt bridges with Glu and Asp to stabilize collagen [3], [4]. Although the aromatic residues, such as Phe, Tyr, and Trp, are highly disrupting for triple helices [5] and rarely occur in natural collagen sequences, they play essential biological roles. For example, Phe interacts with integrin α2β1 in the motif GFOGER of [6], [7], and CH-π interactions of Pro and Phe could induce higher-order assembly of collagen fibrils [8].

The quadrupole moment of an aromatic ring of Phe/Tyr/Trp could interact with basic residues such as Lys or Arg, which is called cation-π interactions [9]. The cation-π interactions play an essential role in protein stability [10], [11]. Since basic and aromatic residues coexist in collagen [12], a question has been raised whether cation-π interactions could also stabilize collagen.

Recently, some of interchain cation-π interactions in collagen have been characterized with host-guest study, which has further been utilized to induce the formation of heterotrimers and higher-order assembly of collagen [13], [14], [15], [16].

Side chain interactions in collagen could be location- and residue-dependent. There are two major types of interactions i.e. an axial Y to X′ and lateral Y to X position in two adjacent chains of GXYGX′Y′. The switching of residues between Y and X′/X position had significant effects on the strength of salt bridges [4], [17]. The similar situation could occur for cation-π interactions, so a set of systematic experiments should be made to enumerate all possible pairs and dissect two types of interactions.

Due to the high stability of Pro/Hyp in triple helices, homotrimeric sequences such as (POG)n and (PPG)n had long been used as hosts to contain axial and lateral pairs of amino side chains [3], [13], [18]. Increase of the melting temperatures of YGX motifs could indicate axial interactions, while the XYG motifs could show lateral ones. However, there are two major disadvantages of homotrimeric hosts. First, two axial and one lateral interactions simultaneously exist in the YGX motifs. Secondly, when n and m residues are, respectively, at Y and X/X′ positions in the pairs, n × m peptides should be synthesized for the pairwise interactions. In contrast, a single interaction pair could be pinpoint in a heterotrimeric host, since a mutation does not occur cross three chains. For n × m pairwise interactions, only n + m peptides are synthesized and combined into n × m pairs.

In order to characterize side chain interactions in collagen, a heterotrimeric host should ideally have three features. First, the heterotrimer should be the most stable among all the 27 possible association stoichiometries and chain registries. The (POG)10 homotrimer was more stable than the heterotrimer, (POG)10:(EOG)10:(PRG)10, Hartgerink et al. made a pioneering design of heterotrimer, (POG)10:(EOG)10:(PRG)10, of which the component, (POG)10, could form a more stable homotrimer [19]. Secondly, an obligate 1:1:1, rather than 2:1 or 1:2 stoichiometry is required in order to prevent coexistence of other interchain interactions. For example, a heterotrimer (PKG)10:(DKG)10:(EPG)10 designed by Hartgerink et al. could be used [20]. Thirdly, high-resolution structural information should be known in order to clarify the specific chain registry among six possible ones of 1:1:1 association stoichiometry and precisely pinpoint interchain interactions. A recently resolved crystal structure of collagen heterotrimer, abc, could be an ideal platform to characterize the interchain cation-π pairs (PDB ID: 5YAN) [17], [21].

Based on the abc structure, a library was constructed containing 15 peptides with single mutations at three locations, which were combined into double mutations to measure stabilizing effects (ΔΔTm) of 12 axial and 12 lateral cation-π interactions between Phe/Tyr/Trp and Arg/Lys. Occurring frequencies of the cation-π pairs in natural collagen sequences were calculated and correlated to ΔΔTm, which helps us gain insights into the mechanisms of collagen folding.

Section snippets

Peptide synthesis

The peptides were made with a solid-phase FMOC synthesis method, then went through reverse-phase HPLC to obtain the 95% purity of the products, which were verified with mass spectrometry at GL Biochem (Shanghai) Ltd. (www.glbiochem.com). We confirmed molecular weight and purity of the peptides in our laboratory with HPLC and mass spectrometry (Fig. S1). The peptides were uncapped in both N- and C-termini. The first letter of a mutant peptide represents its original peptide, which is followed by

Constructing a mutation library to screen for side chain interactions

Without disrupting the existing salt bridges of heterotrimer, abc, (PDB ID: 5YAN) [17], Pro10 at Y position in chain b could make a lateral interaction with Hyp9 in X position and axial one to Hyp12 at X′ position in chain c (Fig. 1). Each of these three locations was mutated to three aromatic (Phe/Tyr/Trp) and two basic (Arg/Lys) residues, where 15 mutant peptides were synthesized in total. Three aromatic mutants of chain b were mixed with the original chain a and two basic mutants at the X′

Conclusion

Five axial, i.e. FK, YK, WK, RF, and RW, and one lateral, i.e. RF, cation-π pairs between aromatic and basic side chains in triple helices were screened with a heterotrimeric peptide library containing 15 single mutations and 24 double mutations. Statistical analysis showed that axial RF is used most frequently in natural collagen, while the other pairs, such as FK, YK, WK, were rarely found. Except for the cation-π interactions, Arg plays an important role in the binding of integrin α2β1 [6],

Acknowledgement

This work was supported by 1000 Plan of China (K2069999) and NSFC of Jiangsu Province (BK20151126), NSFC (51603089), National First-class Discipline Program of LITE (LITE2018-03) to FX, NSFC (21603088) and NSFC of Jiangsu Province (BK20161066) HNZ.

Cited by (6)

  • Improving catalase stability by its immobilization on grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella) scale collagen self-assembly films

    2019, Materials Science and Engineering C
    Citation Excerpt :

    CL is safe and non-toxic compared to the industrial synthetic reagents in the above studies. CAT can expand the application range of CAT [3,4]. According to the three methods in Fig. 4, after the CAT activity and the stability of the operation, the effect of GTA concentration on the adsorption method and the embedding method was investigated experimentally. (

View full text